Episode Twenty Eight

The conversation around this book reveals the fascinating dichotomy in how our hosts approach fantasy romance. We debate pure entertainment value and emotional impact versus technical criteria regarding world-building consistency and character development. This tension between “enjoyable escapism” and “cohesive fantasy craftsmanship” mirrors broader debates within the romantasy community.

Particularly compelling is how Yaros expands her magical system, introducing the Irids and revealing more about the balance of powers. The hosts passionately debate whether these elements feel organic or retrofitted, with one describing the book as “building the ship as she flies it.” Meanwhile, the romantic relationship between Violet and Xaden sparks heated discussion about communication issues.

Beyond the story itself, the hosts tackle the concerning trend of romantasy authors delaying publications due to mental health concerns. They question whether fan expectations have become toxic, whether publishing demands are unsustainable, or if the multi-faceted role of modern authors (writer, marketer, social media personality) creates impossible pressure.

Onyx Storm by Rebecca Yarros
Goodreads | Amazon